Eclectic Architecture

By Mark W. Canada, A.I.A., Architect

Eclectic Architecture

As an architecture student many years ago I still recall an epiphany of consciousness. I was standing in a subterranean vault surrounded by 1000+ year old Roman walls of the medieval walled town of Basil, Switzerland. The colored fresco walls were ancient yet recently refurbished. On the worn stone floor I envisioned sandal clad Roman soldiers dutifully performing their work. Embedded in the stone walls were ancient heavy timbers used as structural lintels supporting stone ceilings overhead. But before me there were ½” thick floating glass walls, finely machined stainless steel hardware and high tech cable lighting exhibiting contemporary artwork! The dichotomy of materials was astounding! Ever since, I have wanted to emulate that degree of eclectic architecture.

Since that memorable moment of recognition 32 years ago I have had several other occasions of contrasting materials making beautiful impressions on my mind as an architect. There is simply nothing more beautiful to me than the juxtaposition of the old with the new, the worn with the polished, the solid with the void, the contemporary with the traditional and the light with the heavy. Feng Shui friendly design is conscious of this principal as a harmonious balance in nature unlocking the mysteries of environmental energy. Eclectic architecture offers a richness that is not possible by adhering strictly to a single style or genre of design, no matter how expertly detailed and exquisitely executed. To me, Eclectic Architecture is the ultimate expression of architecture as living sculpture. In fact, we have designed a few residential projects that intentionally look as if they are historic restorations of old buildings that have then been added onto in a contemporary style simply to contrast and create Eclectic Architecture.

The abstraction and distillation to a simpler application of a recognizable style is called Mannerist architecture. This is not Contemporary Architecture; the most commonly misunderstood two words in the English language. Leonardo Di Vinci practiced Mannerist architecture, rebelling against his noble clients in the design execution of their manors and retreats when asked to design something in the style de jour-Neoclassical/ Roman Revival.

The buzz word you hear these days in the construction industry is “green building.” It makes me smile because we as architects have been practicing passive solar architecture for 40+ years now, and it has just recently undergone a rebirth with a new name. Building with sustainable building materials with the aim to save fossil fuel while both building the structure and maintaining it during its life-use cycle is finally recognized by developers and builders as environmentally conscionable. Renovations and additions are the epitome of ‘Green Building’, in that they save and reuse energy that would otherwise be destroyed. If passive solar energy techniques can be incorporated in the remodels and additions, along with incorporation of an eclectic design approach; well, that is what we as architects dream for.

[TOP]